"If you close one day and people drive by and see that you're closed, they're automatically going to think you're closed all the time, forever," chef Tony Rinella told the Valley News in October. This week, The Baited Hook at Mascoma Lake is closed, and its lot on Route 4A sits empty.
The closure is the problem he described, and it is temporary. The restaurant is closed November 2 through 18 while new operators get ready. When it reopens, it will be serving breakfast and lunch Wednesday through Saturday, with a menu written from scratch. For anyone on the lake side of Lebanon, the place they pass every day is about to fill a different role in the winter routine.
A short closure, and the same people on the other side
The handoff is going to familiar faces. Tony and Lisa Rinella, who grew up in Grafton County and now live in Enfield, are taking over the restaurant. According to the Valley News, Lisa Rinella's announcement says a transition team will "gradually take on daily operations and ownership" over the winter. Tony will run the kitchen and Lisa will handle the business and hospitality side. He has been a chef for more than 30 years and has cooked at The Baited Hook since 2023, so the person writing the new menu already knows the kitchen.
The Rinellas stepped in after the business had been on the market for two years. Dawn and Billy Beattie bought the restaurant from the Carroll family in 2020 and own it with two partners. The restaurant's own history says Patty and Chris Carroll opened it as a seasonal spot in the mid-1980s. The Beattie family's camp on the lake goes back to 1932.
Dawn Beattie told the Valley News the restaurant might have had to close this winter. Instead, the plan is a short closure followed by a longer run. Down the line, the Rinellas plan to buy the building as well as the business.
What comes back on the menu
For years, The Baited Hook's identity has rested on fried seafood and summer, and the fried seafood is staying. The rest of the winter menu is new. Rinella has written breakfast and lunch menus from scratch, with nearly 50 new items between the two. The Valley News reported these specifics:
- The Mascoma Monster, a hot dog Rinella described as "a hotdog I've always dreamed of"
- Fried seafood, kept on the menu alongside the new dishes
- Homemade takeout meals, including two casserole-style dishes and a soup that changes every week
- Events, with trivia and holiday parties among the plans
The takeout meals may be the biggest change for nearby households on a weeknight. "I can do better than a burger," Rinella told the paper. "How about I make you dinner for your whole family?" Prices for the new items haven't been published.
Why breakfast, and why four days a week
The winter schedule follows the restaurant's staffing. The Baited Hook runs with about six people now. In summer it can grow to as many as 25, because the outdoor seating and the ice cream window bring in that much more business. With the patio and ice cream stand closed for the season, a small crew can cover breakfast and lunch four days a week.
The Beatties kept limited winter hours for the past five years. The Rinellas told the Valley News they think some people still believe the restaurant closes for the season, and they want to spread the word about winter hours. Making breakfast the focus is part of that effort. "I hope breakfast and lunch drives quite a lot of business. There's not a breakfast spot around here," Lisa Rinella told the paper.
The closest familiar breakfast option is on the other side of the city. Four Aces Diner in West Lebanon lists breakfast and lunch from 7 a.m. to 2 p.m. daily on its website. Doug and Stephanie Allard have owned it since April 2025, according to the Valley News. Once The Baited Hook reopens, households near Route 4A will have a breakfast stop on their own side of town, overlooking the water.
When the weather warms up, the plan is to go back to breakfast, lunch and dinner.
The hours posted online are out of date
The restaurant's website still shows its "Fall 2026" hours: Wednesday through Sunday, 11:30 to 8:00. That schedule ended with the November closure. The new winter days are set, Wednesday through Saturday, but the opening and closing times have not been announced. The closure runs through November 18, so the first chance at the new menu would be the Wednesday or Thursday after.
Before you drive over, here is how to check:
- Call the restaurant at 603-632-1113.
- Email [email protected].
- Watch baitedhook.fish for updated winter hours.
The address doesn't change: 83 NH Route 4A, Lebanon.
After breakfast, once the lake freezes
The Baited Hook's winter plan also puts a warm meal close to the lake's main winter activity. Last winter, after a year off, the all-volunteer Mascoma Lake Skating Association arranged for Lowery Property Services of White River Junction to plow rinks and skating loops on the lake once the ice was thick enough for the equipment. The Valley News reported the loops could be reached from the Mascoma Lake Boat Launch at 253 Route 4A and from Shakoma Beach across the road in Enfield. Parking was in a lot on the opposite side of Route 4A, with a crosswalk to the beach.
That was last season's arrangement. The association has said it depends on the weather, and the 2024 hiatus came from trouble finding someone to plow and from unreliable ice in warmer winters. Ice conditions are posted on the association's website and its Facebook page. Check there for this winter's plans, and never assume the ice is ready because the calendar says it should be.
If the lake isn't ready, the in-town option last winter was the Pat Walsh Park ice rink on Bank Street Extension. It was open 8 a.m. to 10 p.m., weather permitting, with skates available to borrow.
On a cold Saturday, a skater can be on plowed lake ice with breakfast just up Route 4A at a restaurant that, as recently as this fall, might have closed for the winter.
If you're thinking about a lake-area home and want to know how that stretch of Route 4A works in every season, Andy Clouse can walk you through it. Let's Connect.